Puzzle Academy, an Uncle Logic publication. Puzzles, logic, deduction, strategy.

Lockstep Extreme · Solving lessons

Lockstep Extreme: When a Solvable Puzzle Becomes Impossible

You're playing Lockstep Extreme.

Both pieces are moving. You're getting closer to the goals. Everything seems to be going reasonably well.

Then something changes.

You try moving left. Then right. You backtrack, change direction, and try a different approach.

Nothing works.

Here's the uncomfortable possibility: you may have made the puzzle impossible to solve.

Not because the puzzle was broken. And not because it never had a solution.

Because somewhere along the way, you entered what's called a dead state.

What is a dead state?

In Lockstep, every move affects two boards at once.

Both pieces receive the same movement command, although obstacles can stop one piece while the other continues.

Those obstacles are often exactly what you need to solve the puzzle. They let you change the pieces' positions relative to one another, even though you can't control them separately.

But they can also create problems.

A dead state is a position from which no possible sequence of legal moves can finish the puzzle.

That's different from being stuck on a difficult step.

If there's still a path to both goals, even a long or surprising one, you're not in a dead state.

If every possible continuation fails, you are.

And the frustrating part is that you might still be able to move around the boards. Having available moves doesn't necessarily mean you still have a winning route.

The discovery that helped create Lockstep Extreme

Dead states actually played a role in the creation of Lockstep Extreme.

During development of one of the earliest versions of Lockstep, we were blind-testing puzzle difficulty when something unexpected happened.

A perfectly solvable puzzle became impossible to finish.

At the time, we hadn't even identified the concept as a dead state.

Then it happened again during the same testing round.

That raised an important design question.

Should a player working through their daily puzzle be able to unknowingly make it impossible?

Regular Lockstep had already gone through considerable difficulty testing, including feedback from beta testers whose difficulty assessments largely matched our own.

We wanted challenging puzzles. But we also wanted the Daily experience to feel approachable, without the additional burden of worrying that one mistake could permanently eliminate the solution.

So we made a distinction.

Regular Lockstep would emphasize puzzles designed to remain recoverable.

The more punishing possibilities weren't discarded.

They helped inspire a separate game: Lockstep Extreme.

How does a winning position turn into a losing one?

Think about what happens when one piece hits an obstacle.

That piece stays put while the other can keep moving.

This creates an opportunity to change the relationship between the two boards.

Sometimes you need that exact opportunity to bring both pieces to their goals.

Now imagine making a different move that eliminates your ability to create the required alignment later.

The move might look harmless. It might even bring one piece closer to its destination.

But if you can no longer arrange the pieces in the positions needed to finish, the puzzle has become unsolvable.

That's what makes dead states interesting.

The danger isn't necessarily the move you're making. It's the moves that might no longer be possible afterward.

Can you recognize a dead state before entering one?

Sometimes. But there isn't one simple visual warning that proves a move is dangerous.

A piece being blocked doesn't automatically mean trouble.

Moving away from a goal isn't necessarily a mistake either. Some difficult Lockstep solutions require taking several steps in seemingly the wrong direction.

Instead, try looking one decision further ahead.

If a piece needs to move independently of the other, where can you use an obstacle to make that happen?

If you change their relative positions now, will you still have opportunities to adjust them later?

And if a move seems to make immediate progress, are you overlooking something it prevents you from doing?

These questions won't mathematically guarantee that you're avoiding a dead state.

But they encourage you to think about preserving possibilities instead of simply reducing the distance to the goals.

What should you do if you're stuck?

First, don't assume the puzzle is impossible just because you can't see the solution.

Lockstep Extreme contains plenty of difficult puzzles that remain solvable even after long detours.

Try reconsidering which board needs to move and which one might need to stay still. Sometimes the breakthrough comes from deliberately moving away from a goal.

If you determine that you've entered a dead state, however, continuing to move from that position won't solve it.

You'll need to return to an earlier position using Undo, or restart the puzzle.

The useful question becomes: where did the last recoverable position turn into an unrecoverable one?

Understanding that turning point can teach you more than simply memorizing a solution.

Not every Extreme puzzle has dead states

One last thing worth knowing: Lockstep Extreme isn't exclusively about dead states.

Some puzzles are difficult because of longer solutions, more complicated obstacle arrangements, larger boards, or additional pieces that must move together.

Others include the possibility of entering genuinely unwinnable positions.

Both belong in Lockstep Extreme.

The difference is that you're being asked to think more carefully about the consequences of your moves.

Give it a try

The next time you play Lockstep Extreme, try thinking about more than how close your pieces are to the goals.

Pay attention to the obstacles that let one piece move while another stays still.

Consider which future arrangements you'll need.

And remember that a legal move isn't necessarily a safe one.

Play Lockstep Extreme on Uncle Logic and see whether you can preserve a path to the solution.