Puzzle Academy, an Uncle Logic publication. Puzzles, logic, deduction, strategy.

Classic Sudoku · Solving lessons

Classic Sudoku: How to Find a Number Without Guessing

You open a Sudoku puzzle.

There are a handful of numbers scattered across the grid, dozens of empty squares, and nine possible digits to choose from.

Where do you even start?

Here's the trick: you're not actually choosing numbers.

You're figuring out which numbers have nowhere else they can go.

Once you start looking at Sudoku that way, even a nearly empty grid becomes a lot less intimidating.

Three rules, one answer

Every standard Sudoku puzzle follows three basic rules.

Each row must contain the numbers 1 through 9 exactly once.

Each column must contain those same nine numbers exactly once.

And each 3×3 box must do the same.

That means every empty square has three sets of restrictions working together.

A number might be missing from the row, but if it's already somewhere in that square's column, it cannot go there.

The same goes for its box.

Your job is to find the squares where those restrictions leave only one possible answer.

Start with a square that has only one choice

Imagine an empty square in the second row of a Sudoku grid.

A · Focus on row 2, column 8
Original 26-given nine-by-nine teaching puzzle, not a dated Daily. Column and row numbers outside the grid are coordinates. The highlighted empty square R2C8 is a question mark. Row 2 has 7 at C1, 1 at C4, 2 at C5, and 6 at C7. Column 8 has 3 at R8 and 8 at R9. The top-right box has 4 at R3C7 and 5 at R1C9. All other displayed numbers are original givens.
The question mark is R2C8. Outside numbers label rows and columns. Large dark digits are givens.

The row already contains 1, 2, 6, and 7.

See the candidates after checking the row
1 · Check the row
Enlarged pencil-mark square for R2C8. Remaining candidates: 3, 4, 5, 8, 9. Crossed-out digits have been eliminated by the rows, columns and boxes already inspected. Row 2 already has 1, 2, 6 and 7. Five choices remain.

Looking down its column rules out 3 and 8.

See what the column removes
2 · Check the column
Enlarged pencil-mark square for R2C8. Remaining candidates: 4, 5, 9. Crossed-out digits have been eliminated by the rows, columns and boxes already inspected. Column 8 adds 3 and 8. 3 is at R8C8. 8 is at R9C8.

Then the surrounding 3×3 box rules out 4 and 5.

See why only 9 remains
3 · Check the box
Enlarged pencil-mark square for R2C8. Remaining candidates: 9. Crossed-out digits have been eliminated by the rows, columns and boxes already inspected. The box adds 4 and 5. 4 is at R3C7. 5 is at R1C9. Only 9 remains.

That's eight numbers eliminated.

Only 9 remains.

It doesn't matter that most of the puzzle is still empty. You've proved that this particular square must contain 9.

This is called a naked single.

The name sounds technical, but the idea is simple: one square, one possible number.

Now try looking at it backward

Here's a slightly different situation.

Suppose you're trying to figure out where the number 4 belongs in a row.

Several squares are empty.

One of those squares could still contain 3, 4, or 8. So looking at that square by itself doesn't tell you the answer.

But look across the entire row.

After checking the columns and boxes, you discover that every other empty square has already ruled out 4.

That means the square with three possibilities must contain 4.

Why?

Because every row needs a 4, and that's the only place left for it.

Inspect the hidden single in the same puzzle
B · Row 6 has only one place for 4
Same original teaching puzzle after the proved 9 was entered at R2C8, shown with a ring. The five other empty cells in row 6 contain crossed-out 4s: R6C1, R6C2 and R6C3 are excluded by the 4 at R4C1; R6C4 by the 4 at R1C4; R6C7 by the 4 at R3C7. Those source givens are double-underlined, distinct from the ringed placed 9. The other cells in row 6 already hold 9, 1 and 7. Only R6C5 allows 4, even though its enlarged pencil marks are 3, 4 and 8. The 4 has not yet been entered. Crossed-out digits are exclusions, not placements.
Underlined 4s are givens. Crossed-out 4s are exclusions. Ringed 9 is the earlier proved placement.

This is called a hidden single.

The difference is worth remembering:

A naked single is a square with only one possible number.

A hidden single is a number with only one possible square in a row, column, or box.

Both are guaranteed deductions. Neither requires guessing.

Every answer gives you new information

Here's something easy to overlook.

When you place a number, you're not just solving one square.

You're also removing that number as a possibility from every other square in its row, column, and box.

C · Before entering the proved 4
Column 5 from the same board after naked single 9 at R2C8. The source square R6C5 still displays pencil candidates 3, 4 and 8, but the row has already proved it must be 4. The neighboring square R8C5 has exactly two candidates, 4 and 8. Enlarged squares make both sets readable. Row numbers label the column context. Other unknown cells do not show a complete pencil-mark set.
Only the two relevant pencil-mark sets are expanded here. Blank cells do not imply that they have no candidates.

That can create another single.

Enter the 4 and see the next single
Place 4, then prove 8
Enter the proved 4 at R6C5, shown ringed in the column context to distinguish it from givens. Because R8C5 shares column 5, 4 is removed from its previous candidates 4 and 8. R8C5 is still unfilled in the column context. Its enlarged square shows crossed-out 4 and remaining candidate 8, proving the next placement. Other unknown cells do not show complete pencil marks.
The crossed-out 4 is removed from R8C5 because both cells share column 5. Ringed large digits are proved placements.

And that new single might create another.

It's why a Sudoku puzzle that seemed impossible a few moments ago can suddenly start falling into place.

After every successful placement, take another look at the surrounding areas.

You might have created an opportunity that wasn't there before.

What about pencil marks?

Sometimes the possibilities aren't obvious just by looking.

That's where pencil marks come in.

Instead of committing to a number, you can record the numbers that might still belong in an empty square.

For example, if a square could contain either 2 or 7, those two candidates are useful information.

Later, if another deduction eliminates the 2, you've found your answer.

Uncle Logic's Daily Sudoku includes pencil marks to help you keep track of these possibilities.

You don't need to fill every empty square with candidates immediately, though. Start with the areas where you're close to finding something definite.

When you're stuck, change your question

If you can't find a square with only one candidate, stop searching for one.

Instead, choose a number.

Ask where that number could go in a particular row, column, or box.

Sometimes changing the question is all it takes to discover a hidden single.

And remember: a number fitting somewhere doesn't prove it belongs there.

You want a reason it must go there.

Give it a try

The next time you start a Classic Sudoku, see how many numbers you can place without guessing.

Look for a square with only one possibility.

Then look for a number with only one available position.

Keep switching between those two approaches, and pay attention to what each new placement changes.

You might be surprised how much of the grid you can solve using just those two techniques.

Play Classic Sudoku on Uncle Logic and see what you can prove.